...
Stylized black rose centered with two leafy branches extending outward, adorned with small dots and berry-like shapes on either side—a design reminiscent of the elegant touches you might find at a charming bed and breakfast Toms River NJ.

Our Tea Menu

Download Printable Menu
Victorian tea menu with elegant floral borders, featuring tea sets, scones, and beverage options, along with pricing and reservation details at the bottom. Pink and cream tones create a vintage, inviting feel—perfect for an afternoon at a charming tea room in Toms River, NJ.
Catering and take-out menu featuring homemade scones, soups, tea sandwich trays, dessert trays, charcuterie boards, tea varieties, and tea cups—perfect for gatherings or special occasions at our charming tea room in Toms River NJ. Pink and gray decorative accents add an elegant touch. Prices and contact information are included at the bottom.
A decorative tea menu lists various teas and their descriptions—including oolong, black, green, chocolate, cardamom, cranberry, peach, and herbal blends—set against a floral vintage background with gold and pink accents, evoking the inviting charm of a classic tea room in Toms River NJ.
Menu with ornate pink and gray borders listing various teas and their descriptions, divided into regular and decaffeinated options. Perfect for any tea room in Toms River NJ, this menu also includes contact info and website details at the bottom. No images of tea cups or people are present.
A vintage black and white photo of a man and a woman sits above an article about the history of the Mathis House, a historic Victorian tea room Toms River NJ inn.
A letter from Alice Priest, owner of Mathis House, describing the mansion’s rich history and charming amenities—including our beloved tea room in Toms River, NJ—while warmly inviting guests to share photos and reviews. Contact details and social media information are provided at the bottom.

 All of our Afternoon Tea menu items are made fresh daily at the Mathis House.  We are open Tuesday to Sunday from 11 to 4 pm.

Our best-selling Victorian Afternoon Tea service is served in five courses and tea service typically will be a two-hour experience served by our professional wait staff on delicate china.

The name of this Afternoon Tea is the Sir Mathis Thomas Full Afternoon Tea and the cost is $50.00 per person plus tax & gratuity.  Vegetarian options and Gluten-Free ($10 up charge fee) Options are available.  Reservations are recommended in advance for the full tea but walk-ins are acceptable if there are seats available.

The  five-course Victorian Afternoon Tea includes:

  • A warm cup of our home-made soup which are seasonally prepared
  • A seasonal bowl of fresh salad
  • Scone of the Day, served with clotted cream and lemon curd
  • A plate of a variety of five traditional tea sandwiches and savories
  • A full plate an assortment of finger-sized desserts
  • A full Pot of Tea with over 80 gourmet varieties to choose from

The Mathis House was voted one of the best Tea Rooms in New Jersey.  Attire may include your favorite Victorian outfit and hat!  This is a one of a kind experience that has visitors from all over the country coming to enjoy the Mathis House.

For custom events and parties, please call the Innkeeper to plan your perfect tea party! To view our full tea menu, please click the box below.

Tea Reservation
Order online with DoorDash. Just as you might follow precise steps on how to brew the perfect cup of tea, DoorDash delivers a seamless experience. The DoorDash logo, a red stylized wing, appears next to the brand name in bold red letters on a white background.
Download Printable Menu
Scroll to Top